The song list for Christmas on Fifth Avenue that have played during previous Holiday Seasons:
- THX – THX Electrical Failure
- Brian Setzer Orchestra – Jingle Bells
- Brian Setzer Orchestra – Nutcracker Suite
- Brian Setzer Orchestra – Sleigh Ride
- Brian Setzer Orchestra – You’re a Mean One Mr. Grinch
- Disney – Believe In Holiday_Magic
- Faith Hill – Where Are You Christmas
- Father Ted Berndt – Soldier’s Silent Night
- Guy Lombardo – Auld Lang Syne
- Harry Connick Jr. – Let It Snow, Let It Snow, Let It Snow
- Josh Groban – Believe (The Polar Express Soundtrack)
- Kate Smith – Silver Bells
- Kenny G – O Christmas Tree
- Lou Monte – Dominick the Donkey
- Mannheim Steamroller – Little Drummer Boy
- Marty’s Remix – Angels We Have Heard on High
- Marty’s Remix – Its the Most Wonderful Time of the Year
- Mavis Staples – Christmas Vacation
- New Years Countdown
- Polar Express Suite (The Polar Express Soundtrack)
- Tom Hanks – Hot Chocolate (The Polar Express Soundtrack)
- Tom Hanks – The Polar Express (The Polar Express Soundtrack)
- Trans-Siberian Orchestra – Boughs Of Holly
- Trans-Siberian Orchestra – Christmas Canon
- Trans-Siberian Orchestra – Christmas Eve (Sarajevo)
- Trans-Siberian Orchestra – March of the Kings
- Trans-Siberian Orchestra – Wizards of Winter
- U2 – Christmas Baby Please Come Home
- Vince Guaraldi Trio – Linus and Lucy